Best Buy Brings Back 4K Blu-ray

Best Buy is selling 4K Blu-ray discs again, nearly three years after it dropped physical movies. I don’t think discs were ever phased out for being bad. Digital is cheaper and more readily available for most consumers.

The return is slow. Best Buy lists 14 titles on its website, and only The Odyssey has reached store shelves so far. When Best Buy announced it would end disc sales in 2023, space was part of its stated reason: the change, it said, gave it “more space and opportunity to bring customers new and innovative tech”.

My own problem with physical media was always where to put it. VHS, books, application discs, game cartridges and discs, and then Blu-ray on top. To their credit, Blu-ray cases kept to the slimmest form factor possible and were reasonably shorter than DVD cases, but they were still taller than the discs inside. Collectors sometimes throw the boxes away to save space. Journalists and reviewers, who would no doubt have many boxes themselves, often talk about it.

That space has a price, because furniture takes floor space before it holds a single disc. I won’t put a number on it, but the method is simple: pick a bookcase, count how many discs fit, divide the floor space it takes by that count (that’s each disc’s monthly rent-free living in your house), and add the furniture’s price. None of that math needs to be done for digital, streaming or a one-time purchase.

Best Buy selling discs again is rather reminiscent of Flexplay. The idea was that the disc would expire 48 hours after opening, and in 2008 it was supposed to be sold through Staples for $4.99. But even in 2008, physical discs sold through stores were bad ideas. In 2008, I already had access to Redbox, the vending machine of DVD rentals, and Flexplay was discontinued only three years later. For a non-collector like me, the limit on buying movies back in the day was space, and digital took that limit away.